Sunday, May 14, 2006

Sticky Toffee Pudding Icecream with Brandy Snaps


I love icecream. I love trying new flavours. One the highlights of our trip last year to Japan was the opportunity to try matcha (green tea), sweet potato, black sesame seed, and sake icecreams. The first icecream of summer is an event of great ceremonial celebration; and if it occurs on an unseasonably glorious day in March, then so much the better. And, isn’t just amazing how at the end of a large meal, a scoop or two of icecream still manages to slither down the hatch…

Inspired by a fabulous idea dreamt up by Rob at Hungry in Hogtown for entry in the recent St. George’s day English pudding event, I just had to make a batch of sticky toffee pudding icecream to try for myself.

Sticky toffee pudding, as Rob discovered, is not a English pudding of great antiquity, but it is a dessert that is well known across the country, and one that features on the menus of eateries from homely hostelries to hoity-toity hotels. I think it deserves the accolade of 'modern classic', and is undoubtably a recipe that will have great longevity. It has an association with the Lake District, as the recipe apparently originated from the kitchens of The Sharrow Bay Hotel, that stands on the shores of Lake Ullswater, Penrith, Cumbria. The hotel was established in 1948 by the late Francis Coulson and Brian Sack. Francis was by all accounts a bit of a genius in the kitchen. He devised the recipe (originally called 'icky-sticky toffee sponge) back in the early 1970s. He was never precious about the recipe, and passed it on to whoever asked for it. However, there does appear to be a rival claim for the pudding from another Cumbrian hotel; the chef of which set up Cartmel Village Shop, in the small town of Cartmel to produce and sell the puddings commercially. If you live in the UK, then you will probably have seen Cartmel Sticky Toffee Puddings in your local supermarket. They are very good indeed.


On a cruise around Waitrose I discovered that Cartmel Village Shop also produce a Sticky Toffee Sauce. Made with only sugar, cream, butter and vanilla essence, it tastes as naughty as you might expect. Keep it out of sight, to try and keep it out of mind.

For the purposes of this recipe I bought two Marks and Spencer Sticky Toffee Puddings, as it would have been too distressing to mulch up a Cartmel pudding, and too much effort to make my own simply to use as an icecream base. The M&S puddings come in packs of two individual servings, and the quantity was pretty spot on for Rob's recipe.


A couple of notes on the making of the icecream - I took the instruction to caramelise the pudding to mean simply heating the broken pudding in its own sugary sauce. I did this over a pretty low heat for about 5-8 minutes. I added the sugar with the milk and cream (think Rob forgot to mention this). The resulting icecream had a intense flavour, but I think (for my tastes) could have benefited from a reduction in the amount of molasses used. The treacley taste was a little overwhelming. However, that aside this was a luxuriant creamy take on an already top-tip pudding.

To set off the smoothly dense icecream I decided make some brandy snaps. Brandy snaps are a form of thin, crunchy, sticky and slightly chewy ginger biscuit, made and consumed across the country. Historically they have come in differing forms, but now they are generally rolled into a tube shape when still warm. The cooled tube can then be filled with cream to serve.

Laura Mason and Dorothy Hartley both classify brandy snaps as wafers - which are thin biscuits made in a wafering iron, with heat applied to top and bottom surfaces of the biscuit. (Click here to see some historical wafers). Mason suggests that wafers (as sweet biscuits) developed from the plain wafers produced in Catholic countries for use celebrating the Eucharist. Now, it seems to me that there is quite a long journey to be made from Communion wafer to brandy snap, so I'll take Ms. Mason's word for this. Alan Davidson in the 'Oxford Companion to Food' describes the biscuits as, 'crisp, lacy baked items which stand on the frontier between biscuits, wafers and sugar confectionery.'


To me this sounds a better summation of what brandy snaps are; I can find no recipe that requires wafer tongs to cook them, instead they are oven baked on a metal sheet. I think that they could be successfully made on a flat griddle, which is perhaps closer to the cooking method used for wafers.

Brandy snaps were sold in Britain as another form of fairing (gingered biscuits were a big winner at country fairs it seems), and they came in many shapes and could be made with sugar, honey or treacle, and from the 1880s - golden syrup. Not all recipes include brandy - it seems that the flavour is not really discernable, so to make cheaper batches of snaps it was left out. Some recipes skip out the ginger too, relying solely on the cooked sugar and butter for flavouring. Don't worry, there will be none of that abstinence in this household. The recipe I followed from Jane Grigson's 'English Food' uses both brandy and ginger, and golden syrup lends its deliciously sticky presence to form the basis of the snap.

Brandy Snaps
(quantities given here make 20-30 biscuits - I used half quantities)

125g butter
125g golden syrup
125g granulated sugar
Pinch salt
125g plain flour
2 teaspoons of ground ginger
1 teaspoon of lemon juice
2 teaspoons of brandy

1. Preheat oven to 200C/400F/Gas 6. Prepare a couple of baking sheets with greaseproof paper.
2. Melt the butter, syrup and sugar in a pan over a low heat. Keep stirring, and once the sugar has dissolved take pan off the heat. Leave the mixture to cool.
3. As soon as the mixture is tepid, add the salt, flour, ginger, lemon and brandy. Mix well.
4. Measure out the mixture using teaspoons. You will need to space the dollops out well, so aim for 6 per baking sheet (you can always do a second batch - I did).
5. Jane suggests baking for 8-10 minutes, but I found this too long and the snaps burnt. By my third go I snatched the baking sheet from the oven immediately as a nice deep golden had been achieved.
6. You can shape the snaps round wooden spoon handles, or a rolling pin, and drape them over the base of a glass to form a basket. Be ready to start shaping not long after the biscuits come out of the oven. They might appear too soft, but as soon as you start to work them the mixture seems to magically harden. Hours of fun.


The brandy snaps went well with the sticky toffee icecream, but I had another batch of icecream in the freezer, also freshly churned this weekend -rhubarb ripple icecream (from an old recipe from Sainsbury's Magazine). I felt a bit mean excluding it from the chance of a moment of glory, so I popped a couple of scoops into the only brandy snap basket that I had managed to make, and stuck in a fan of broken snap.


Who needs crockery? I think that there could be a large market for edible tableware...

17 comments:

Rosa's Yummy Yums said...

That sounds and looks very delicious!

juliebean said...

Your ice cream and brandy snaps are so beautiful and look soooo delicious!!! Makes me wish for scratch and sniff computer screens, lol...

Chloe said...

How delicious does that look. That rhubarb ice cream recipe sounds intriguing.... :)

BNA said...

Oh my word. Those are gorgeous.

Jeanne said...

Oh my goodness - that sounds like ice-cream indulgence at its very best! (and yes, isn't it funny how ice cream can be fitted in after the most enormous meal without difficulty? ;-))

Brandy snaps were my total teenage favourite. If it came in/with a brandy snap, I would order it. Always wondered why "brandy" snaps though, as they're basically ginger? Thanks for the recipe - I must give it a try!

anna said...

Thanks ladies!

As the person who got to eat the icecream and brandy snaps, I can confirm that both were very tasty.

Hi Jeanne. I think that it is important (critical) to put the brandy back into brandy snap, not least because it puts to good use the bottle lurking at the back of the drinks cupboard. Perhaps the alcohol works some sort of biscuit alchemy to help form the lacy texture? Sounds like a question for Heston & co.

rachel said...

Love your site! As someone who is hopeless at baking, but who is really intrigued by British cuisine, your blog is a real inspiration. Definitely going to be trying few of these out. Cheers!

I, like the view said...

this post made my mouth water. . .

and brought back memories of my mother making brandy snaps and rolling them around the sweet things wooden spoon

(she had two wooden spoons, one for sweet things and one for savoury things and g*d help you if you used the wrong one whilst assisting her in the kitchen)

then she would pipe them until full with stiff whipping cream

(you were only allowed to eat a second, if you ate the first without the biscuit cracking and crumbling to such an extent that the cream splurged out)(and you weren't allowed to suck the cream out)

love your recipes and photos!

anna said...

Hmm. A brandy snap eating (no cream splurging) competition. That can join the jam doughnut eating (no lip licking) idea as one that I MUST try.

Glad that you liked the view!

I, like the view said...

and can that go along with the tour of London touring establishments that sell those gorgeous custard tarts and eating them on the way round. . .

(from one of your previous posts!!)

I do like the view but it's making me so hungry. . .

Eve said...

Yum! I too love green tea ice cream. Or cinnamon ice cream.

I thought sticky toffee pudding was made with dates? Am I wrong?

Anonymous said...

HI Anna - Ive just 'surfed' in having recently been bitten by the cooking bug. Im a started at 30 years of age and I really enjoy it. Im also really into organic and seasonal meats and veg. Your site is so well designed, the photos are amazing and your wealth of knowledge outstanding. I will enjoy dipping into your blog in the future and 'borrowing' some receipes - with comments of course! Thanks again. Elle (London)

Vallen said...

I spent a month in Great Britain this summer and everyday one of the three in the group had sticky toffee pudding. WOW!! It is the best dessert ever. I found a recipe for it while in England but what I would like to get a recipe for is Rowies or butteries. Can you help?

mollyb said...

Not only does this look amazing, it tastes amazing too - I tried this recipe last night!

Although, must admit, just the brandy snaps - I cheated a little and used some Mrs. Beeton's toffee ice cream. It was a really good substitue, as I'm not quite up for home-made ice cream just yet!

Loving the site btw!

Android 5.0 Jelly Bean said...

How delicious does that look. That sounds and looks very delicious!

Sewa Mobil Bontang said...

aThat sounds and looks very delicious! That sounds and looks very delicious!

plasterers bristol said...

Yummy, my favorite dessert, thanks for sharing this recipe..

Simon